2

A co-worker asked a riddle that got me wondering about the anatomy of books and book binding methods.

The Riddle:

A leaf is torn from a paperback novel. The sum of the remaining page numbers is 15,000. What pages were torn out?

According to the answer (and a lot of the internet), it claimed that a leaf:

is a single sheet bound in a book, and a leaf has two pages.

I thought this assumption was vague and that a leaf can either have two pages or four pages depending on how it is bound. This assumption also changes the answer of the riddle.


Leaf with two page binding:
Two page binding


Leaf with four page binding:
Four page binding

Are both definitions of a book leaf correct? Or is there only one? Is one more commonly assumed than the other?

3

A quick Google search revealed that

Very generally, "leaves" refers to the pages of a book, as in the common phrase, "loose-leaf pages."

A leaf is a single sheet bound in a book, and a leaf has two pages. (Source: Biblio)

A folded grouping of leaves is a "gathering", so the left image under "leaf with 4 pages" in your question is actually a gathering of 4 leaves (8 pages). The right hand image is a gathering of 2 leaves (4 pages)

Note that if you tear one leaf out of a bound book, as books are more commonly bound in gatherings, often one other leaf will also become loose, and maybe fall out — especially if the leaf torn out is in the centre of a gathering. But that is a separate leaf, not the other half of the same.

  • I think your counting is off. The term refers to the front and back of a half sheet as one page, even though numbered it'd be two pages. So the picture would be 1 gathering, 2 leafs, 4 pages, 8 numbered pages. – Web Head May 7 '18 at 4:59
  • 1
    @CreationEdge - No. If you have 8 numbered pages in 1 gathering you have 4 leaves. – Chris Rogers May 7 '18 at 8:07
  • 2
    According to U of Wisconsin, the English Language Stacke Exchange and wikipedia, a leaf has two sides and each side is considered one page. – Wimateeka May 7 '18 at 12:32
  • Which matches what I said @Wimateeka – Chris Rogers May 7 '18 at 13:57
  • 1
    I see the confusion I'm having here, it's the phrase "single sheet bound in a book", yet the illustration we're looking at isn't loose-leaf, so a "single sheet" is actually forming two leaves. A better quote for you here is from the ANSI /NISO/ LBI Library Binding Standard, Z39.78-2000: A single sheet of paper, or one half of a folded sheet of paper. Each side of the leaf is a page. Leaves can be printed or blank. – Web Head May 7 '18 at 17:56

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.